News

Why CJI Surya Kant Shifted Two Cases After They Evolved Into Public Interest Litigations (PILs)

Published On Wed, 18 Nov 2026
Arjun Khanna
3 Views
screenshot_2026_11_18_12160159ab3a1b_f017_41c5_aa0b_2e9cc3dd2f8d
Share
thumbnail

Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant has transferred two cases from the bench of Supreme Court judge Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah following concerns that the proceedings had expanded into nationwide public interest litigation (PIL) matters, according to media reports. The decision was reportedly taken after consultations with four senior Supreme Court judges — Justices Vikram Nath, BV Nagarathna, MM Sundresh and PS Narasimha. The development has brought attention to the Supreme Court's case allocation system and the Chief Justice's authority as the 'master of the roster'.

The two matters were initially filed over individual grievances but gradually expanded to cover wider issues involving private universities and unauthorised construction across the country. The reported concern was that PIL cases were not included in the subject categories assigned to Justice Amanullah's bench. One of the transferred matters, Ayesha Jain vs Amity University, Noida, originated from a student's complaint concerning alleged harassment and the loss of an academic year following a legal change of name. During the proceedings, the case expanded to examine broader questions relating to the establishment, funding, regulation and functioning of private universities across India. The matter also involved directions and responses from government authorities.

The case, which was earlier heard by a bench comprising Justices Ahsanuddin Amanullah and NV Anjaria, has now been assigned to a three-judge bench headed by Justice Vikram Nath. Justices R Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh are also members of the bench. The matter is scheduled for hearing on November 19. The second case, Loganathan vs State of Tamil Nadu, relates to alleged unauthorised construction and commercial use of residential properties. The proceedings began on March 25, 2026, following a complaint concerning the construction of a building in Chennai without an approved building plan. The matter subsequently expanded into a broader examination of unauthorised construction and land-use violations in different parts of the country.

During the proceedings, the Supreme Court also sought responses from state governments and municipal authorities, including those in Delhi and the National Capital Region. Senior advocate Ajit Kumar Sinha was appointed as amicus curiae, with advocate Govind Jee assisting him. The case has now been assigned to a bench led by Justice BV Nagarathna and is scheduled to be heard on November 23. The transfers have once again highlighted the importance of the roster system in the Supreme Court. Under this arrangement, the Chief Justice determines which judges will hear particular categories of cases and constitutes benches accordingly. The Chief Justice's administrative authority in this regard is commonly described as the 'master of the roster'.

The Supreme Court has previously clarified this principle in important judgments. In the 2017 case of Campaign for Judicial Accountability and Reforms vs Union of India, a five-judge Constitution Bench reaffirmed the Chief Justice's authority to allocate judicial work and constitute benches. Similarly, the 1997 judgment in State of Rajasthan vs Prakash Chand recognised the Chief Justice's administrative role in distributing cases.

The latest decision does not determine the merits of either dispute. Both cases will continue before their newly assigned benches. However, the development has renewed discussion about judicial discipline, case allocation and the procedures that must be followed when individual complaints develop into wider public interest proceedings.

Disclaimer: This image is taken from NDTV.